Owned by the same family for decades, this striking waterfront post and beam construction sits on serene 1.8 acres overlooking Gardiners Creek and Sylvester Manor. With incredible privacy and ample room for a pool and accessory structures, the property is perfect for indoor/outdoor lifestyle and entertaining with a generous open floor plan and multiple decks. Soaring cathedral ceilings and countless oversized windows create a home filled with natural light. Two fireplaces, radiant heat throughout the main living space, three en-suite bedrooms, and a large loft. This waterfront beauty is ready for its next owner to put their stamp on it with a material palate ideally suited for a designer's eye. There are no like-kind alternatives to this unique Shelter Island opportunity., Additional information: Appearance:Mint,Separate Hotwater Heater:Y